I hate my shakes thin!! I find that really weird as i HATE smoothies for there thickeness, even weetabix - I have to have it really thinned out with milk else I gag, yet the shakes - I only make with 200ml water so they are nice and thick, weird that isn't it!! I only have the vanilla (rarely), mostly chocolate, both mixed with coffee powder (decaff) and the coconut flapjacks. I'm trying the soup for the first time this tonight, the chicken one! I'm quite excited in a weird way!! hehehe!