My doctor gave me them without the counselling and me losing weight prior to going on them which on further consultation with the nurse is not practical. The nurse wasn't happy that this is what happened and wanted to take me off them. I refused and told her I wanted to continue on them as they were working for me. Maybe if you sit down with the GP and explain to him and prove to him you are determined he may reconsider. failing that ask to be refered to weight management