This is such a difficult topic for me, as it is for everyone that has responded so far.
A year ago I was that person who would HIDE wrappers, plan my binging around the times when my boyfriend wasn't home, or even when he went out the room I'd be in that cupboard looking for something to stuff down myself as quick as possible. The more unhappy I became with myself, the more I turned to food especially when I felt lonely and bored. After all, food is a friend that never abandons you. Food is always there for you no matter what. ... wrong.
Abstinence on LL and group sessions with counselling actually helped me think about it properly. Why was I acting this way? In the end it's my own inadequacy to face my problems that made me turn to an easy answer, a quick fix. But no problem can be avoided forever, it will always come back unless it's resolved. I know this now.
My BMI is now normal, and is at it's lowest than it's been since I was born. I have always been a fat child, at the age of 14 I was size 18-20. I know a lot of food as comfort has come from my family - they have never been great at solving problems - the answer is always usually 'Have something to eat!'. You're in pain? Have a cake. You had a bad day? Have some chocolate. You're feeling ill? Have something tasty. ...
Now I know I *used* to be a huge pasta addict, used to adore just chewing on something all the time. ... A 9 month period of abstinence made me see that I don't have to be that fat girl anymore because I could change. I can see I'm an addict and I freely admit it. After abstinence I actually SEE that get more energy from eating an apple in the day than eating a piece of toast, and my mood is definitely better! I no longer care much for pasta to be honest.
I quit smoking about a month ago and I get cravings still. I'm on LLLite plan which actually doesn't feel like a diet compared to the mainsteam LL plan at all. But I do get cravings for starchy/sweet food, except that I have no escape this time from the cravings! This is as pure as it gets because whenever I tried running from food I'd run straight to my friend Nicotine. Now I can't do that anymore and have to face my food demon face-to-face and ask it the most direct questions that I can;
WHAT DO YOU WANT? WHY HAVE YOU COME? HOW CAN I DESTROY YOU?
I ask these questions every time, and usually I may still want whatever I was craving, however I thought about the emotion attached to it, and I work on my feelings instead of longing for food. I don't run from my cravings and neither should you... You just need to admit and allow your feelings to come to the surface, admit that you're feeling vulnerable. It's hard to admit that you need a bit of help as well sometimes, don't be afraid to ask for a hug.
I deal with secret eating habits by actually announcing when I have something to eat, whether there is someone to hear it or not. My boyfriend thought it was a little odd at first, but I explained it to him and he was happy that I had shared something that was so personal to me. After a while you will find you no longer need to announce it because you'd come in the habit of not having to hide it. After all, secret eating often revolves around guilt and shame... which would no longer be there.
I space out my meal times if I'm caught in-between I have an apple or some vegetables. If there's not much time to go I WAIT for the right time to get especially hungry and feel proud that I've waited!
However, there is ONE more thing I need to deal with... which is DEPRAVATION. How do you get around it? The reason I feel that many of us go back to our old habits is that we often feel on healthy eating plans, on abstinence we DEPRIVE ourselves of that cream cake/chocolate/crisps - whatever it is for you. It may be a conscious or a subconscious feeling, that yearning, a want that is unsatisfied because you're not allowing yourself to have it. This is a serious issue for me personally since I feel it is the last hurdle I need to jump across.
I have partly begun to deal with it by not cutting out my triggers completely, but allowing myself a small portion every other day (I buy a small bar of Galaxy which is 250 kcal each) and have it in the evening. I don't actually think about it at all until it's time for 'dessert' after dinner! So, I have a controlled portion, in moderation.
I think when it comes down to it, we need to accept our flaws, not run from them. If you have a problem with cream cakes, then have one. But learn to have ONE and learn to have satisfaction from knowing that you have controlled yourself. It will come easier with time I think.
Any other ideas as to how to deal with this hurdle?