Indeed Bernice, I agree with you. I know for me, I've known all about what I should eat for years, but it's taken until now, when I've worked through some of my own issues, to be ready to let go of the food / weight as my crutch (and even then, I'm wobbling a bit now, as it's scary to totally change how I will look) I think we need to be careful in judging either the girl or her mother - we're all here because we've eaten more than we should have done (to greater or lesser degrees) and I know I'm not the only one here losing weight for the second time - ok, so this girl has big numbers, but it's only more exaggerated behaviours that each of us has been guilty of in one way or another. I just hope I can really learn from it and find the strength to keep the weight off this time.