Okay, so let me get this right. You do all this, and intend to for the rest of your life because you
think Scott prefers you slim. He has never indicated this, it's just what you have invented yourself. In fact, he might even prefer you bigger

Some men do you know
I know he preferred my chest pre diet
Has to put up with chicken fillets falling out all over him now!
My stepfather hated skinny ladies. Said the big ones were more feminine, cuddley, curvy, sexy.
But you think that he might, so it's worth the effort. Okay, so look at it this way. Just imagine that Scott says to you "Lovely Tracey....but what I really want if for you to be 20 stone". Just out of interest, what would you do? Would you do that for him? Would you want to be 20 stone, trouble getting clothes, out of breath, chaffed skin, hot and sweaty, difficulty moving, shorter life span with more chance of diabetes etc. Would you do that?
No I wouldn't do that! I probably haven't worded this as I should have. I got the impression in one of your posts (I'm going to go back and read them again now) that you stated that I had lost weight for other people i.e. Scott, rather than for myself, because I had said that I couldn't understand how he could want me as I was. I tried to say that this was my warped view of things and not as they actually were. So I've tried to say that I don't feel I've done it for him, I feel I've done it for me.
Very true. But losing weight so that others approve isn't enough.
I totally agree, for the dieting to work and to then stay slim, is something we have to do for us, I do feel I've done it for me, but I also like the fact that I get nice comments from friends and family etc. too. In fact, I have had the odd remark to the contrary. I told a friend of mine that I'd put on a couple of pound after my last holiday and she told me that it probably was a good thing as I was getting too skinny
I know I'm not skinny and although her comment threw me a bit, it didn't make me think I should perhap put on a bit more. Main comments now are 'oh you look great, but don't lose anymore' Lol I'm not trying to
Ahhh, that is slightly different. Did it make you feel good because you made people happy, or did it make you feel good because people approved of what you were doing?
If you enjoyed the job for it's own sake and the joy you got out of cheering people up and helping them, then you can keep it going indefinitely. On the other hand, if you had to do this day in day out for every waking moment just so people go home and tell their spouses what a wonderful person you are, how long could you keep that up for?
So it depends on why it's making you feel good.