Oh hunny, there's nothing amazing about my willpower I assure you. I was exactly the same as you until this past year, I tried everything from weight watchers to Cambridge and never lasted more than 3 weeks! The only reason I started losing weight last year was to pass the occupational health check to get onto a radiography degree! I still find it crazy that I started losing weight for my career prospects rather than my health, even though I was almost 25 stone!!
From what you've said I think a psychiatrist/counsellor might actually be able to help. Surely that need you feel isn't a physical need for bad food, it's a mental one, so there must be some explanation for it. I used to be really sceptical of counselling/therapy but after having panic attacks a couple of years ago it really helped me. It doesn't have to cost the earth either, I got 6 sessions of counselling free from work after my manager suggested I ring the staff advice line. Apparently a lot of big companies do things like that, so maybe worth looking in to see if your place offers anything similar. Its confidential obviously!
Our experiences are so similar in a way, when Chris was working late or I had some time off I used to go to the shops to buy loads of crap/order takeaway and eat it all without him knowing. Then I'd eat again when he got in!!
Bloody mental. :sigh: I never had the need for one specific thing like the kebab though... I just wanted EVERYTHING!
Do you think sticking to a weekly weigh in will help your losses? For me it does and I'd be lost without it, but if you don't think it'd help then it doesn't make sense to follow a diet you don't agree with. What aspects particularly about SW don't you like? I don't follow the plan to the letter and find some bits a bit daft too. For example, some of the 'free' food options like mugshots I don't think are particularly healthy with all the preservatives etc, so I choose not to have them. I also tweak the plan a bit, so for example mullers are syn free but contain 100 cals, so to mix things up I substitute them with other yoghurt's with the same cals/fat content. And of course I don't eat 'unlimited' anything, it's nice to know options are available if I'm starving but I'm still conscious that I'm trying to lose weight and don't go completely overboard with second portions etc.
I think you pretty much know what you need to do and what will work, it's just a matter of getting a plan together on how to get started and figuring out some strategies for getting through the cravings. Food for yesterday sounded yummy, I love M&S salads! xxx