I am assuming from that comment you have never had any contact with the actual surgical procedure or hypno-procedure?! I have a friend who has a 'real' band and lost 10st at the rate of 1.79lb per week. She hasn't lost any more weight for a year because, like anything, it takes time and extra work. The band, real or not, has to be worked with, it does provide a physical restriction but that can be sabotaged if you don't work with it properly.Sorry to completely butt in here! 8lbs in 5 weeks isn't that much, not for someone that has a gastric band (considering you're meant to be the same as someone with an actual one after hypnotherapy). That's a little over 1.5lbs a week which is highly doable doing anything else such as calorie counting, weight watchers, slimming world etc. and so, personally, I'm not sure that I see that it's worth the cost.
I have a friend with a real band and it sure isn't a miracle! It is hard work and there is a lot of pain involved, food gets stuck in it which needs to be regurged or 'helped' through. While I don't get these things with the virtual one I do feel very ill if I eat too much. I have to consider everything I eat as if I snack on something unhealthy I wouldn't be able to eat anything else (healthier!) for an hour or 2. If I don't eat nutritious food I also end up feeling illI dont take part with the boards much but just wanted to say 8lbs in 5 weeks is great !
The "real" gastric band isnt a miracle it doesnt make you drop weight ive been researching this op since oct 2010 and although it does help to restrict how much you can eat, the whole process from Op to what they call the "sweet spot" can take 12 months or more. In my opinion this form of weight loss surgery is the one that needs tweeks and extra willpower
(all weight loss needs this though).
It is actually easier to eat bad foods with the band as they tend to slip through the band pretty easily.
Im not sure if you feel this with the hypno band though.
Taz i think youve had a great loss over the past few weeks xx
I am assuming from that comment you have never had any contact with the actual surgical procedure or hypno-procedure?! I have a friend who has a 'real' band and lost 10st at the rate of 1.79lb per week. She hasn't lost any more weight for a year because, like anything, it takes time and extra work. The band, real or not, has to be worked with, it does provide a physical restriction but that can be sabotaged if you don't work with it properly.
Feel free to belittle my success but you don't know my full story, this thread is JUST about the hypno-band. I have medical reasons why weight loss is difficult for me and before the therapy I'd lost 1lb in 4 months at SW. The therapy was the tool I needed to start losing weight again and it worked. If I lost 1lb a week I would be happy as any loss is good.
Not everything works for everyone and I would say that hypnotherapy would not work for you, just as other ways don't work for me
I did see your second post after I posted and I appreciate your comments. For the record, I didn't pay hundreds of pounds and nor would I without the guarantee of success. I went into it as a gamble of less than £100 which I considered worth it at the time as I was paying more going to SW and losing nothing. I now see it as an absolute bargain as I have lost weight since, and more!Actually yes, I have. I know quite a few people who have had the 'real' band and the majority lost at a much faster rate than that. One ate less but all bad things so lost very slowly. Another lost something like 1 stone a month, possibly a little more. The others lost quite quickly too.
As I clearly said in my second post, I didn't mean to sound like I was belittling your success in any way, I think that losing anything is good. My point was that you've paid a lot of money for something that isn't providing a very fast weight loss, in comparison to those that I know that have had the band. No, I don't know your story BUT you haven't put that here, you've just pt about the band and your losses and so obviously, that's going to be all that I have to go on.
Like I have said to you in my post before, 8lbs, however you've lost it is great and so I in no way turn my nose up at that. But I do still stick to my original point which was that, for the average person, that amount can be lost through other methods which won't cost however many hundreds of pounds. I agree, some methods will work for some, whilst some won't work with others so I'm glad that you've found what works for you.
It's not completely effortless, you have to stay on the ball or it can unravel. But if the therapist does a good enough job beforehand you will NEVER eat the same again. So in that respect it is easier, but it's not infalibleThe point being, with hypnoband weight loss, there is very little effort needed - the weight comes off on it's own, not by calorie counting, avoiding mixing proteins and carbs like other well-known diets, etc.
If I lost 8lb without much effort, I'd be pleased as punch, even if it did come off 1lb a go.
Well done, Taz. Keep it up!
I did see your second post after I posted and I appreciate your comments. For the record, I didn't pay hundreds of pounds and nor would I without the guarantee of success. I went into it as a gamble of less than £100 which I considered worth it at the time as I was paying more going to SW and losing nothing. I now see it as an absolute bargain as I have lost weight since, and more!
Hi Alli, I have lost another 2lb this week which I am very pleased with. Now I know it works I would definately pay the full price for it, it's the not knowing that makes it a risk. And it won't work for everyone, you have to be really up for it and positive towards it.I also saw something on TV about this recently and did a search on here and came across your post! Well done on your loss so far!
I understand Caroline's comment, but if I'm being completely honest with myself I've probably spent £150 - £200 on diet related stuff in the past year and that was a good year. Some of the things that I've paid for in the past 5 years are:
£80 for SW membership
£500 approx for Cambridge Diet (lost 3 stone )
£30 for WW membership
£20 for memberhsip of a intuitive eating website
£60 for SW membership (yes I've signed up several times)
£100 (I think) for Beyond Chocolate
£200 for life coaching - which included emotional eating
Various books such as South Beach, The Harcombe diet, diet cook books etc etc etc
I'm sure I've missed some out - £350 for a hypno band is a bargain if it works!!
I find it absolutely fascinating and will follow this thread with interest - please keep us up to date with your progress!!!
Taz said:Hi Alli, I have lost another 2lb this week which I am very pleased with. Now I know it works I would definately pay the full price for it, it's the not knowing that makes it a risk. And it won't work for everyone, you have to be really up for it and positive towards it.
I am interested to know, when you had the life coaching for emotional eating did it help at all? Emotional eating is one of the biggest changes in my life now, the hypno sessions have completely removed that and it's amazing!