thanks ML i will deffo have to try halls next time i am ill, i have no idea why but lockets actually silence my caught and really work for me, my oh thinks they are rubbish hates them its weird what works for some doesn't others, i have some sugar free sweets from m&s the ones in the boxes, they do like worthers and mints, orange & lemons and some strawberry ones i used to have them for the car when i got dry mouth and didn't have water etc. i was worried about what sweeteners they had in them n didn't want to scupper my loss after reading all the posts about the sugar alcohols etc so not had any in a while. Do you know if they are ok? or do they have the evil ingredient?