Aw sorry Carrotina I know it can get frustrating. I was in your position a few weeks ago and here is a cut and paste of one of the conversations on another 5:2 thread which really makes sense now:
"I was really good last week and didn't look at the scales at all until friday morning (I fasted tues & thurs) and I still didn't lose anything. I know someone will respond asking how many calofres I've been eating on regular days but I thought the whole point of this was that you didn't need to count calories on your non fast days. I generally eat a bagel and a banana for breakfast, tuna or cheese sarnie for lunch with a couple of biscuits, for tea it's usually something like Fish fingers beans and mash and a twix or a crunchie. I'm fasting again today and thursday and if I've not lost anything after that I'm going back to slimming world - It might be restictive on some things each day but at least it still worked for me"
"People are advised to eat 'normally' on non fast days, unfortunately most of us end up over weight because we don't know how to eat normally. I'd recommend calorie counting at least one day just so you know that you're staying under your recommended level"
"Hi Deb, have to agree with what fizzy said, we are all dieting because we can't eat 'normally', either because of portion size, eating the wrong things or putting on weight due to medical reasons. Why not try My fitness pal for a week, log everything, weigh everything and see what you are eating. At least you will know if you are over eating. No diet is one size fits all. I'm losing weight but that is due to this diet + exercise. I eat too much for it to work on its own."
Now this is where I was gonig wrong you see. When I started tracking my non fast days I found even on days when I thought I wasn't gonig mental I was still having a HUGE amount of calories. One of my main issues is portion control. Plus even just tracking the calorie content of a few of the main foods I eat I was shocked by the high calorific values of some of the items. Now it's not to say that I don't still have them...I just try to balance things out a bit more. Hope this all makes sense. It may not apply to you of course but I wanted to share it as it's really opened my eyes a lot.