FullFathom
Full Member
Okay. Gosh. I think you might be being just a **little** bit spikier than you really need to be, but that's okay, dieting does that to our moods.
What I was trying to get across, was that perhaps 'one' could possibly afford to be just a bit more positive about the likelihood of successs? It might even make that success more likely if one is able to think of a future where one simply has a healthier lifestyle without food as its focus at all. Perhaps it isn't necessary for 19 out of 20 of us to become be regarded as a freak or junkie for that to be the case? Perhaps eating three healthy meals a day and taking up a regular active past-time is actually plausible?
One fear might be that if one decides that only gym junkies and health freaks can succeed and that 95% of people will get obese again, then not only is that setting a scene and excuse for failure, it's linguistically establishing quite a rigid mindset. It might be continuing a notion that there are fat people and gym people, failures and freaks etc..? A mindset that while certainly benefitting the dieting industry, can still surely be challenged? Hence my challenge.
There's no need for a fact fight here, but I've also read a fair bit about nutrition and dieting. And I too have railed against the seemingly cyclical nature of dieting. And I got very moody and moaned loudly on my diary about the fact some people seem to just take on dieting as a lifestyle in itself. The whole 'we mean it this time', 'this is my time (again)' thing is symptomatic of that, and (hoho!) hard to swallow at times, although if that's fun in itself for some people, then fine I guess.
Some people seem to have been on diets for decades. They have shelves of books that record a modern history of dieting fads. It's making other people a fortune, but not making them thin or happy. This is one route, and it's valid. But just maybe another route might be that if you really want it, then really do it - then move on with a new focus other than what to consume next.
Of course its okay to decide that putting it all back on is simply inevitable, and that an old dog cannot be taught new tricks without becoming a professional puppy etc... But maybe iit is also possible to get to a comfortable weight and stay there by just living more sensibly? I've certainly seen it happen. Perhaps the sweat and tears of many months on magic powder can provide enough time and anguish for some people to realise that they're done with that? And perhaps a more active life without eating obvious crap is not only possible, but actually enjoyable?
Horses for courses, though, natch.
What I was trying to get across, was that perhaps 'one' could possibly afford to be just a bit more positive about the likelihood of successs? It might even make that success more likely if one is able to think of a future where one simply has a healthier lifestyle without food as its focus at all. Perhaps it isn't necessary for 19 out of 20 of us to become be regarded as a freak or junkie for that to be the case? Perhaps eating three healthy meals a day and taking up a regular active past-time is actually plausible?
One fear might be that if one decides that only gym junkies and health freaks can succeed and that 95% of people will get obese again, then not only is that setting a scene and excuse for failure, it's linguistically establishing quite a rigid mindset. It might be continuing a notion that there are fat people and gym people, failures and freaks etc..? A mindset that while certainly benefitting the dieting industry, can still surely be challenged? Hence my challenge.
There's no need for a fact fight here, but I've also read a fair bit about nutrition and dieting. And I too have railed against the seemingly cyclical nature of dieting. And I got very moody and moaned loudly on my diary about the fact some people seem to just take on dieting as a lifestyle in itself. The whole 'we mean it this time', 'this is my time (again)' thing is symptomatic of that, and (hoho!) hard to swallow at times, although if that's fun in itself for some people, then fine I guess.
Some people seem to have been on diets for decades. They have shelves of books that record a modern history of dieting fads. It's making other people a fortune, but not making them thin or happy. This is one route, and it's valid. But just maybe another route might be that if you really want it, then really do it - then move on with a new focus other than what to consume next.
Of course its okay to decide that putting it all back on is simply inevitable, and that an old dog cannot be taught new tricks without becoming a professional puppy etc... But maybe iit is also possible to get to a comfortable weight and stay there by just living more sensibly? I've certainly seen it happen. Perhaps the sweat and tears of many months on magic powder can provide enough time and anguish for some people to realise that they're done with that? And perhaps a more active life without eating obvious crap is not only possible, but actually enjoyable?
Horses for courses, though, natch.